The DCMP Captioning Key
The DCMP Captioning Key is guidance from the Described and Captioned Media Program for captioning educational media, not a law. Of the 4 elements CaptionPass grades, a caption file settles presentation rate and partly settles line count and division, speaker identification and non-speech information. Whether captions match what was said needs a person.
What is the DCMP Captioning Key?
A set of guidelines for captioning educational media, published by the Described and Captioned Media Program, which the U.S. Department of Education supports. The Key says it is a key for the vendors who caption for DCMP, and that it applies to anyone captioning media. Read the Key.
A media library may ask its captioning vendor to follow the Key. That makes it a contract term, not a legal duty.
Do we have to follow it?
Not by law. The Key states no legal requirement. The rules that bind public bodies name WCAG instead: ADA Title II names WCAG 2.1 Level AA, and Section 508 names WCAG 2.0 Level A and AA. The Key is useful beside them because it says what good captions look like in more detail than either.
What does the Key ask of a caption file?
CaptionPass grades 4 of its elements. Each is quoted below with how much of it a caption file can settle.
| Criterion | What it requires | What a caption file can settle |
|---|---|---|
| presentation-ratePresentation rate | Captions are presented at no more than 130 words per minute for lower-level educational media and 160 words per minute for upper-level. | CheckedThe caption file is sufficient to settle this. A pass here is a real pass.Checked at the upper-level ceiling of 160 words per minute, per caption: the words on screen divided by the time the caption is shown. Lower-level media has a ceiling of 130, which this check does not apply, so a pass here does not show a lower-level file meets it. |
| line-treatmentLine count and division | No more than two lines per caption is preferred; three- or four-line captions are occasionally acceptable. A sentence broken across lines is broken at a logical point where speech normally pauses. | Partly checkedThe file can show this failing, but cannot show it passing. No findings means nothing detectable is wrong — not that the criterion is met.A caption of more than 4 lines fails, checked on the file as delivered. Whether three- and four-line captions are only occasional is not checked, and neither is whether lines break at logical points. The Key sets no line length, so none is checked here. |
| speaker-identificationSpeaker identification | Speaker changes are identified so the viewer can tell who is speaking. | Partly checkedThe file can show this failing, but cannot show it passing. No findings means nothing detectable is wrong — not that the criterion is met.A half-applied convention is detectable. Whether an unlabelled cue needed a label depends on who was speaking, which needs the audio. |
| sound-effectsNon-speech information | Sounds essential to understanding are described, in square brackets, distinct from dialogue. | Partly checkedThe file can show this failing, but cannot show it passing. No findings means nothing detectable is wrong — not that the criterion is met.The convention is checkable wherever a description is present. Whether a sound was missed entirely needs the audio. |
Cited from Described and Captioned Media Program, Captioning Key: Guidelines and Preferred Techniques (dcmp.org/learn/captioningkey, as retrieved on 2026-11-16).
What can a caption file alone settle?
Checked: the file is enough to decide these.
- Presentation rate. Checked at the upper-level ceiling of 160 words per minute, per caption: the words on screen divided by the time the caption is shown. Lower-level media has a ceiling of 130, which this check does not apply, so a pass here does not show a lower-level file meets it.
Partly checked: the file can show these failing, but not passing.
- Line count and division. A caption of more than 4 lines fails, checked on the file as delivered. Whether three- and four-line captions are only occasional is not checked, and neither is whether lines break at logical points. The Key sets no line length, so none is checked here.
- Speaker identification. A half-applied convention is detectable. Whether an unlabelled cue needed a label depends on who was speaking, which needs the audio.
- Non-speech information. The convention is checkable wherever a description is present. Whether a sound was missed entirely needs the audio.
What needs a person?
Everything that depends on what was said or shown. The Key’s first element of quality is accuracy: errorless captions are the goal, and it gives no percentage. Only a person comparing the captions with the video can judge that, and the same goes for a speaker nobody labelled or a sound nobody described. Caption accuracy requirements explains how that is measured.
Where does this come from?
- DCMP Captioning Key: Described and Captioned Media Program, Captioning Key. Checked .
- DCMP Captioning Key, Elements of Quality Captioning: The Key's five elements: accurate, consistent, clear, readable and equal. Checked .
How CaptionPass uses these grades on a library is on CaptionPass for compliance.
This page describes the rules as published and where they stood on 16 November 2026. It is not legal advice.
What this is not. A conformance receipt is evidence of what was checked, by which engine, against which version of which standard, and what it found. It is not a legal opinion or a safe harbour. The engine that issues it reads the caption file and never the audio, so anything that needs the audio — above all whether the captions match what was said — is reported as not evaluated rather than assumed. On the audit, Program and Contract, a person also samples accuracy, comparing clips with the video by hand, and the report states the sample size and what it supports. How accuracy is measured.